Team Goemkarponn
PANAJI: The High Court has set aside the conviction of Parsappa Kormal in a 2017 POCSO case, granting him acquittal after concluding that the evidence presented by the prosecution was insufficient to establish his involvement beyond reasonable doubt.
The order overturns the Goa Children’s Court verdict of December 7, 2018, as well as its subsequent order dated January 10, 2019.
The allegations stemmed from an incident said to have occurred on July 17, 2017, when the child, then approximately nine to ten years old, had reportedly stepped out to collect buttermilk. The prosecution alleged that she was taken to a cowshed and sexually assaulted.
Following the child’s disclosure to her mother, a police complaint was filed later that evening. An FIR was registered, and the child was subjected to a medical examination the next day.
During the trial, the prosecution relied on the child’s account of the incident, her mother’s testimony and the medical and forensic findings. The Children’s Court had accepted this evidence while finding Kormal guilty.
On appeal, however, the High Court undertook a fresh examination of the material on record. In its 49-page ruling, it found serious flaws in the manner in which the trial court had evaluated the evidence, describing its conclusions as perverse and legally unsustainable.
Adv. Esha Ghodekar, appearing for the defence, had questioned the reliability of the prosecution’s case by drawing attention to inconsistencies in the child’s different accounts of the alleged incident.
The High Court found that her courtroom testimony differed in significant respects from the statement she had previously given before the Magistrate. The variations related to important aspects of the alleged occurrence, including the circumstances at the location and the sequence of events thereafter.
According to the Court, these were substantive differences affecting the credibility of the prosecution’s narrative, rather than insignificant variations that could be attributed to a lapse in memory.
The forensic evidence also failed to establish a direct link between Kormal and the alleged offence. Although human semen was detected in the child’s mouth swab, the prosecution had not produced DNA analysis or any comparative scientific evidence identifying the accused as its source.
The Court therefore held that the forensic finding, by itself, could not establish the appellant’s involvement.
Finding that the prosecution had not proved the essential facts required to sustain the charge, the High Court concluded that the statutory presumption against the accused could no longer be relied upon.
The judgment also invoked *dubio pro reo*, the legal principle that an accused must receive the benefit of reasonable doubt. It emphasised that the possibility of someone having committed an offence is not equivalent to proof that the person necessarily committed it.
Reiterating that suspicion cannot take the place of legally admissible proof, the High Court allowed the appeal and acquitted Kormal.







