As the debate over the proximity of liquor shops to schools and temples continues, it raises important questions about the impact of such establishments on the sanctity of these locations.
The recent revelation that as many as 269 liquor stores are situated within 100 meters of schools or places of worship has sparked significant controversy and led to discussions on whether these establishments should be permitted to operate in such close proximity to hallowed spaces.
The coastal Pernem region has the highest number of these outlets, with 63 liquor stores located within the specified proximity to schools or temples.
Notably, the temple town of Ponda is home to 61 such outlets, indicating a significant presence of liquor establishments near places of worship.
The issue is further complicated by the fact that 15 new licenses have been granted in the last five years, from 2020 to the present, despite the concerns raised about their close proximity to educational institutions and places of worship.
In response to this contentious issue, the Goa government recently amended the Goa Excise Duty Rules to impose a 100% license and renewal fee on liquor licenses granted to establishments situated 100 meters or less from places of worship or educational institutions. This move has been met with mixed reactions, with opposition leaders accusing the government of facilitating the sale of alcohol near sacred sites. However, Chief Minister Pramod Sawant clarified that the rule had been in effect since 1980 and that permissions had been granted by various administrations over the years, including the Congress, on an individual basis.
The revelation that the Excise Department granted 15 new licenses to bars and liquor stores located within 100 meters of schools across various regions of the state in the past five years has underscored the need for a comprehensive reassessment of liquor licensing policies. The distribution of these licenses, including six in Salcete in 2021 and one each in Bardez, Tiswadi, and Ponda in subsequent years, highlights the pervasive nature of this issue across different regions of Goa.
Furthermore, the recent decision by the Supreme Court to recall its order to close down all liquor shops within 150 meters of educational institutions and other locations in Puducherry has added another layer of complexity to the ongoing debate.
The court’s acknowledgement that its decision was based on a 2017 judgment that was subsequently modified underscores the evolving nature of the legal framework surrounding the establishment of liquor shops near sensitive locations.
The Impact of Liquor Shops
Near Schools and Temples
The proximity of liquor shops to educational institutions and religious places has been a topic of debate for many years. The coexistence of these establishments raises concerns about the potential impact on society, especially on young students and the sanctity of religious spaces.
One of the primary concerns associated with liquor shops near schools is the potential exposure of underage students to alcohol. Educational institutions are meant to be environments that foster learning, growth, and positive influences. Having liquor shops near schools increases the risk of students, especially teenagers, gaining access to alcohol. This can lead to an array of issues including underage drinking, substance abuse, and related behavioral problems. Moreover, the presence of liquor shops near schools could send the wrong message to students about the acceptability of alcohol consumption, potentially normalizing its use at a young age.
Additionally, the presence of liquor shops near temples and other religious sites raises ethical and moral concerns. Places of worship are intended to provide a sense of tranquillity and spirituality, serving as havens for introspection and solace.
The intrusion of liquor shops near these sacred spaces could compromise their sanctity and diminish the reverence accorded to them. It may also lead to social issues and confrontations within the community, as the coexistence of alcohol vendors and religious institutions can undermine the spiritual and moral values upheld by followers of a particular faith.
Furthermore, the proximity of liquor shops to temples and schools can have a detrimental impact on the overall ambience and safety of these areas. The increased foot traffic near liquor shops may create a sense of unease and discomfort for both students and worshippers. This could potentially lead to an adverse environment where safety and well-being are compromised.
In light of these concerns, it is crucial to consider the potential repercussions of allowing liquor shops to operate near schools and temples. Local authorities and policymakers should be cognizant of the broader implications and take proactive measures to regulate the establishment of liquor shops in close proximity to educational and religious institutions. Stringent zoning regulations and community consultations should be employed to safeguard the interests of students, worshippers, and the community at large.
The presence of liquor shops near schools and temples can have far-reaching implications on societal values, public health, and the sanctity of religious spaces. It is essential for stakeholders to carefully evaluate these implications and implement measures to mitigate the potential negative effects. By prioritizing the well-being and ethical considerations of the community, steps can be taken to ensure that educational and religious institutions remain spaces that uphold positive values and provide a safe environment for all.
