Team Goemkarponn
PANAJI: Karnataka has challenged the Centre’s decision to hold back approvals for the Kalasa-Bhandura water diversion scheme, arguing that the reasons cited for withholding clearances have no legal basis.
In its submission, senior Supreme Court counsel Mohan Katarki maintained that Goa’s challenge to the Mhadei Water Disputes Tribunal award and an order issued by the state’s Wildlife Warden on March 29, 2023, cannot prevent Karnataka from proceeding with the project.
The Centre is understood to have cited the pending Supreme Court proceedings and the Wildlife Warden’s order under Section 29 of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972, while withholding statutory approvals.
Katarki argued that the tribunal award has not been stayed by the Supreme Court and that the mere filing of an appeal does not suspend its operation. He relied on Order XLI, Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure to support Karnataka’s position.
He also questioned the jurisdiction and constitutional validity of the Wildlife Warden’s order, arguing that it was issued against the Karnataka Government and that Goa could not exercise such authority beyond its territorial limits.
The counsel further contended that the Centre could use Section 62B of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, along with Article 256 of the Constitution, to direct Goa to withdraw the order.
The proposed Kalasa and Bhandura schemes aim to divert water from the Mhadei basin into the Malaprabha basin to address drinking water shortages in drought-affected parts of North Karnataka.
Goa has opposed the diversion, citing environmental concerns and its water-sharing interests, while Karnataka maintains that the project is crucial for meeting drinking water requirements.







